Kalshi is continuing its lawsuit against gambling regulators and law enforcement in Ohio and Tennessee. The prediction market exchange operator has asked the US Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals to review a panel decision concerning those cases.
Kalshi referred to a recently published rule for designated contract markets in its rationale for the review. The petition was a foregone conclusion given the text of the new regulation.
Kalshi filed its petition for an en banc hearing in the consolidated case of Kalshi v. Orgel and Kalshi v. Schuler on Tuesday, Oct. 13, 2026. The current opinion came from a three-member panel of the Sixth Circuit in late September.
That ruling affirmed a favorable decision for Ohio officials seeking to enforce the state's gambling laws against Kalshi. The panel simultaneously overturned an injunction barring authorities in Tennessee from doing the same.
Should the court grant the petition, the entire contingent of judges at the Sixth Circuit would review the panel's decision. That could result in a more favorable opinion for Kalshi.
Circuit courts rarely grant such petitions. Kalshi's explanation for why the court should grant the new hearing partially rests on new regulatory movement.

(Photo by Samuel Boivin/NurPhoto via Getty Images)
Kalshi's case for a new hearing rests on asserting that the panel erroneously applied federal securities laws. However, the argument also refers to a new publication from Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) Chair Michael Selig.
In the interim final rule that the CFTC announced on Monday, Oct. 12, 2026, Selig stated that "gambling products" do not qualify as swaps in his estimation. The text of the rule mentions the Sixth Circuit panel's opinion multiple times.
The regulation says that sports event contracts are not gambling products because they are peer-to-peer markets and cleared by CFTC-registered designated contract markets. That conflicts with the Sixth Circuit panel's judgment that sports event contracts do not qualify as "swaps" under federal law.
Kalshi argues that the new regulation "substantially undermine the panel’s holding concerning the meaning of 'swap.'" Whether the full Sixth Circuit rehears the case or not, a higher opinion on the issues may be forthcoming.
While Kalshi was preparing its en banc petition, 39 state attorneys general submitted a joint amicus brief to the Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS) in Kalshi v. Flaherty. The attorneys general support New Jersey officials in their petition to SCOTUS.
That petition asks the justices to review a decision from a panel of the Third Circuit that granted Kalshi an injunction against those officials. New Jersey gambling regulators sent Kalshi a cease-and-desist demand.
Those attorneys general have joined other parties in urging SCOTUS to hear the case. If they do so, the Sixth Circuit's opinion could be overridden.
SCOTUS faces no mandate to take up the case, though. Should the justices pass, Kalshi's en banc hearing request would carry additional weight, as it would be the final word on the legal questions.
Looking for more news and updates? Head over to our Ballislife Play page.
